After Court-Ordered Remand, PGE Seeks New Approval for Stafford Road Transmission Line

November 17, 2026•6 min read

Stafford Road near Johnson Road, 2023 (left) and 2026 (right). PGE completed construction of this northern section of its transmission line while its original County approval was under appeal, before the case was remanded for additional scenic-road findings. PGE is now seeking new approval for the broader project, with a hearing scheduled for December 10. County road improvements also affected vegetation in this area.

After Court-Ordered Remand, PGE Seeks New Approval for Stafford Road Transmission Line

A December 10 hearing tests Clackamas County’s scenic-road protections as residents question the project’s permanent impacts and the evidence behind its claimed benefits.

CLACKAMAS COUNTY, Ore. — A December 10 public hearing will consider Portland General Electric’s latest application for a 115-kilovolt transmission line along Stafford Road, after Oregon’s Court of Appeals upheld a remand requiring Clackamas County to better explain how the project complies with its scenic-road protections.

PGE is pursuing its fourth and fifth land-use applications for substantially the same project. The proposed 5.9-mile corridor would replace modest wooden poles with taller transmission structures, including steel poles reaching approximately 130 feet, add high-voltage wires, and remove roughly 250 trees. Many of those trees now screen homes and farms from Stafford Road. Their loss would expose residents to traffic noise, headlights and views of infrastructure that permanent transmission-clearance requirements would prevent them from fully screening again.

The County already described the impact

In March 2025, the County denied PGE’s request to alter an existing nonconforming utility use. Its findings described the proposal as producing a “far more industrial aesthetic” that was “inconsistent with the current visual identity of the area.” Those words later appeared in the conditional-use litigation. In September 2026, the Oregon Court of Appeals affirmed the remand for additional findings on the County’s scenic-road policies. (Save Stafford Road v. Clackamas County, 352 Or App 770 (2026).)

The County’s Comprehensive Plan calls for protection of “recreation values”, “scenic features” and “natural conditions” along designated scenic roads. Stafford Road north of Mountain Road is one of them. So is Interstate 205 west of the Willamette River, which the proposed line crosses. The County now must confront the visual consequences at both designated roads - not merely whether homes can still be occupied after the trees are gone.

The implications extend beyond individual property owners. Stafford Road is a rural gateway used by farm visitors, residents, cyclists and other travelers. A decision allowing extensive clearing and oversized steel utility structures in a designated scenic corridor could shape how the same protections are applied to future proposals.

What does this particular line actually add?

PGE describes Rosemont–Wilsonville as necessary for electrical reliability. The Oregon Public Utility Commission granted the line a certificate of public convenience and necessity in March 2025, but its decision accepted PGE’s analysis of the line together with the larger Tonquin Project rather than separately quantifying the additional reliability benefit of the Stafford Road segment. (PUC Order 25-125, pp. 17–18.)

Earlier PUC Staff testimony acknowledged that the rest of the Tonquin Project could proceed without Rosemont–Wilsonville and described its added protection as exceeding minimum federal reliability criteria. The modeled problem involves successive transmission-equipment outages. That leaves a practical question for the County’s evaluation of competing policies: What measurable protection does this particular line provide, and could the same objectives be achieved without permanently transforming the scenic corridor? (PCN 6, Staff/100, Kort-Meade/38.)

Who is the projected demand for?

PGE’s own sworn testimony raises another question. In April 2024, Senior Vice President Larry Bekkedahl stated that the line was “intended to address the multiple inquiries for load development that PGE has received.” He identified prospective semiconductor and technology customers in Tualatin, Sherwood and Wilsonville. (PCN 6, PGE/200, Bekkedahl/9, lines 5–10.)

Public land-use records identify approximately 78 acres across two property holdings near PGE’s Coffee Creek Substation and the McLoughlin–Tonquin transmission corridor: Schnitzer Properties’ 54.79-acre Tonquin Commerce Center, annexed into Tualatin in April 2025, and three parcels totaling an estimated 23.5 acres held by Wilsonville Assemblage 5 LLC along SW Grahams Ferry Road. Both entities list the same Portland mailing address. In light of PGE’s sworn testimony about prospective industrial and technology customers in that area, their locations warrant closer examination (City of Tualatin, ANN 24-0001; public-notice ownership records).

Have anticipated developments on these properties - including possible high-demand technology or data-center facilities - been factored into PGE’s demand forecasts used to justify the Stafford Road line? If so, what electrical demand has PGE projected?

PGE sought to withhold the identities of prospective industrial customers from an intervenor during the certification proceeding. In a separate PUC investigation, testimony from the Alliance of Western Energy Consumers, based on confidential PGE data, reported that data centers accounted for the “vast majority” of recent growth in PGE’s industrial rate schedules. The public record does not establish which prospective customers, if any, would use capacity created by the Stafford Road line. It does establish why identifying the projected demand matters. (PCN 6, PGE filing, Dec. 31, 2024; UM 2377, AWEC/100, Kaufman/2.)

PGE is also separately requesting $178.8 million more in annual revenue from customers, citing infrastructure investment and reliability. Oregon’s POWER Act has already prompted a separate rate structure intended to make large data-center customers pay their share. Public officials and ratepayers deserve to know what portion of new transmission capacity is being planned for existing service, committed growth and speculative future demand—and how those costs will be assigned.

A decision with consequences beyond Stafford Road

The question before Clackamas County is not whether electricity matters. It is whether PGE has supplied enough project-specific evidence to justify sacrificing the mature trees, rural views and scenic features that the County expressly designated for protection. A finding that the corridor will have an industrial aesthetic cannot simply be set aside when the same infrastructure returns in a new application.

The December 10 hearing is an opportunity to require a clear, evidence-based explanation of how this proposal complies with the scenic-road policies. The County adopted those protections. Residents are asking it to enforce them.

How to comment

The public hearing on application Z0347-26 is scheduled for Thursday, December 10, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. Written testimony received by November 27 will be considered before County staff issues its report; comments may continue until the hearing record closes. Reference Z0347-26 and send comments to Joy Fields, Principal Planner, at


[email protected]

Sources

· Court of Appeals ruling — Save Stafford Road v. Clackamas County (2026)

· Clackamas County scenic-road policies, Comprehensive Plan Ch. 5

· PUC Order No. 25-125, pages 17–18

· City of Tualatin, ANN 24-0001 — Tonquin Commerce Center annexation

· Tualatin public-notice ownership records — Wilsonville Assemblage 5 LLC parcels

· PUC docket PCN 6, original Staff testimony filed Sept. 26, 2024

· PGE testimony, PGE/200, Bekkedahl/9

· PGE filing objecting to prospective customer disclosure, Dec. 31, 2024

· AWEC testimony, UM 2377, Kaufman/2

· Oregon PUC announcement of UE 473 revenue request

· Oregon PUC announcement of new data-center rate structure

Clackamas County hearing notice for Z0347-26


https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ui=2&ik=3e11dfcc59&attid=0.1.1&permmsgid=msg-f:1882036347449167644&th=1a1e56162814cf1c&view=att&zw&disp=safe

Back to Blog